Police Records vs. Criminal Records: What’s the Difference?

Introduction
When people hear the terms police record and criminal record, they often assume they mean the same thing. However, there are significant differences between the two, and understanding them can be crucial for employment, travel, and legal matters. Whether you’ve had contact with the police in the past or simply want to understand how these records work, this guide will clarify the distinctions and help you determine if and how a record might affect you.
What is a Police Record?
A police record refers to any interaction an individual has had with law enforcement. This does not necessarily mean the person has committed a crime or has been convicted. Police records include a wide range of information, such as:
- Arrest records (even if charges were not laid)
- Police reports and incident records
- Calls for service involving the individual
- Warnings or cautions issued by police
- Non-criminal police interactions (e.g., wellness checks or mental health-related interventions)
- Charges that were withdrawn, dismissed, or resulted in acquittal
Does Having a Police Record Mean You Have a Criminal Record?
No. A police record does not necessarily mean you have a criminal record. Many individuals have a police record without ever having been convicted of a crime. However, some aspects of a police record may still appear on certain types of background checks.
What is a Criminal Record?
A criminal record is a formal record maintained by the Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP) in the Canadian Police Information Centre (CPIC) database. It contains information about convictions and other related legal matters.
A criminal record typically includes:
- Convictions from criminal offences
- Sentencing details (e.g., fines, probation, imprisonment)
- Outstanding warrants
- Certain fingerprints and biometric data
- Court dispositions related to criminal cases
Who Has a Criminal Record?
An individual has a criminal record only if they have been convicted of a criminal offence in Canada. If charges were laid but later withdrawn, dismissed, or resulted in an acquittal, the person does not have a criminal record. However, they may still have a police record unless they apply for record destruction.
How Do Police and Criminal Records Affect Background Checks?
Police Records and Background Checks
Certain background checks may reveal police records, even if an individual has never been convicted of a crime. Employers, volunteer organizations, and licensing bodies may request:
- Criminal Record Checks – Typically show convictions but may include non-conviction records.
- Police Information Checks – May reveal police interactions, withdrawn charges, and even mental health-related police calls.
- Vulnerable Sector Checks – The most comprehensive check, required for positions working with children or vulnerable individuals, which may disclose non-conviction police interactions.
Criminal Records and Background Checks
If you have a criminal record, it will almost always appear on a background check unless you have received a Record Suspension (Pardon). Some employers and volunteer organizations have strict policies regarding hiring individuals with criminal records.
Can You Remove a Police or Criminal Record?
If you have concerns about your police or criminal record affecting your future, there are steps you can take to remove or seal these records.
1. Record Destruction for Police Records
If you were arrested but not convicted, or if your charges were withdrawn or dismissed, you may apply to have your police record destroyed.
This process involves:
- Contacting the police service that handled your case.
- Submitting a formal request for record destruction.
- Waiting for approval, which can take several months to a year.
2. Record Suspension (Pardon) for Criminal Records
If you were convicted of a crime but have completed your sentence and demonstrated good conduct, you may be eligible to apply for a Record Suspension (Pardon) through the Parole Board of Canada.
- Seals your criminal record from standard background checks.
- Improves employment and travel opportunities.
- Typically takes 6 months to 2 years to process, depending on eligibility.
How Do Police and Criminal Records Affect Travel?
Many people worry about how police and criminal records impact their ability to travel internationally, especially to the United States.
- Travel with a Police Record
- If you have a police record but no conviction, the impact on travel may be minimal. However, U.S. border officials have broad discretion and may still deny entry if they deem you a security risk.
- Travel with a Criminal Record
- A criminal record can lead to a travel ban, especially to the United States. The U.S. has access to CPIC records and can deny entry if they find a past conviction, particularly for crimes involving moral turpitude (e.g., fraud, theft, assault, drug offences). If you have been denied entry, you may need to apply for a U.S. Entry Waiver.
Final Thoughts
Understanding the difference between police records and criminal records is crucial for protecting your future. While police records document interactions with law enforcement, criminal records are much more serious and involve actual convictions.
Key Takeaways:
- A police record does not mean you have a criminal record.
- Non-conviction police records can still appear on certain background checks.
- If you were not convicted, you may be able to apply for record destruction.
- If you have a criminal record, applying for a Record Suspension (Pardon) can help remove barriers to employment and travel.
- If denied entry to the U.S. due to a past record, a U.S. Entry Waiver may be required.
If you need help with record destruction, Record Suspensions, or U.S. Entry Waivers, our experts can guide you through the process. Contact us today to take the first step toward clearing your record!
Key Differences Between Police Records and Criminal Records
Feature | Police Record | Criminal Record |
---|---|---|
Includes arrests | Yes | Yes |
Includes convictions | No | Yes |
Includes police interactions | Yes | No |
Stored at local police service | Yes | No (Stored in CPIC) |
Can appear on background checks | Sometimes | Yes |
Can be removed/destroyed | Yes (with request) | Only with a Record Suspension |


